Main

What IS An Indie Author?

what is an indie author

Indie Authors Get Books To Readers in Many Ways Including Trade Publishers

Novelist and ALLi Director Orna Ross considers the (sometimes confusing) question of what exactly distinguishes an indie author.

This post was prompted by an ALLi member who thought she had to leave our Alliance because she had just signed a deal with a trade publisher.

“It’s ironic,” she wrote. “All the great tips I got from you guys is how I sold so many books and that’s why the publisher approached me. Do I have to leave now? I don’t want to.”

“Of course you don’t,” I wrote back. “Lots of our members use trade publishers to reach readers, especially through bookstores. Being an independent author is an approach to writing and publishing, a matter of self-definition. If you see yourself as the creative director of your books, from concept to completion and beyond, then you’re indie. And you make partnerships that help you deliver the best possible book to the most possible readers, trade publishers included.”

I sent her the definition of an indie author from the FAQ page of our website:

At ALLi, “independent” is an inclusive description and always relative (everyone needs help to write and publish well). Some of our members are fiercely indie-spirited, as DIY as it’s possible to be. Others are happy to collaborate with a publisher where that seems advantageous, some working with paid publishing services, others with trade publishers.

So what marks out an indie from other authors? The Alliance allows that you are an independent author if:

  • You have self-published at least one book.
  • You recognise that ‘indie’ does not necessarily mean ‘self-publishing only’ and acknowledge that even the most indie-spirited self-publisher works in collaboration with other publishing professionals (editors, designers, distributors) to produce a good book and reach readers. You are open to mutual beneficial partnerships, including trade publishing deals where appropriate for you, so long as the author’s status as creative director of the book is acknowledged.
  • You expect your status in the partnership to be reflected in contracts and terms, not just lip service.
  • You recognise that you are central to a revolutionary shift in publishing which is moving from seeing the author as resource (in the new parlance ‘content provider’) to respecting the author as creative director.
  • You are proud of your indie status, which you carry into all your ventures, negotiations and collaborations for your own benefit and to the benefit of all writers.

What do you think? Does the definition of indie as creative director of the book make sense to you? What’s your definition? Let us know in the comment box below.

, , , ,

32 Responses to What IS An Indie Author?

  1. Karen Inglis June 18, 2013 at 8:46 am #

    An absolutely perfect definition – which very neatly encapsulates the notion that, whilst retaining ultimate control over your work, you are ready to acknowledge where your limitations are and understand the importance of getting professional help to ensure that you produce a top quality book.

    • Orna Ross June 18, 2013 at 8:02 pm #

      Thanks Karen, it’s the only one that makes sense to me and that fits all our members

    • Melissa S September 4, 2013 at 5:46 am #

      I’ve been writing seven years and am thinking about self-publishing.

      • Ramesh September 17, 2014 at 3:46 am #

        Melissa

        We are a one stop shop for self book publishing. We have many authors who have found success working with us.

        Let me know if we can assist.

  2. Michael N. Marcus June 18, 2013 at 1:08 pm #

    For a while I was a self-publishing snob. I even formed a short-lived group for _independent_ self-publishers who did not use self-pubcos.

    Then I realized that there may not be a heck of a lot of difference between true independents and those writers who prefer the “one-stop-shopping” convenience of using a self-pubco.

    I actually _enjoy_ formatting pages and designing covers — but that’s not a requirement for self-pubbing. Neither is binding books on the kitchen table and selling them from a table by the side of the road.

    There are many paths between writer and reader, and any of them can produce gems or crap. Results count, but little more.

    • ALLi Editorial June 18, 2013 at 1:25 pm #

      Completely agree, Michael. Many of our members use different pathways for different books. Some use intermediaries when starting out, because the learning curve to do direct feels too steep. Or a particular title is complex or requires a certain kind of marketing. There are no rules, each writer must decide depending on circumstances.

  3. Dan Holloway June 18, 2013 at 1:52 pm #

    I’m not sure it’s either possible or necessary to go beyond “a matter of self-definition” as you put it.

    On the other hand – there’s always another hand it seems – that does make it confusing for readers, so I’m not sure how helpful it is to call oneself “indie” in a public-facing forum unless you go on to make that definition – and then even less helpful are umbrella sites that are public facing and about “indies” – what makes indie indie is the lack of fixed definition, which is great, but it must be confusing for readers when different sites mean different things. And that in itself raises questions about how helpful indie-only sites for readers are

    • Orna Ross June 18, 2013 at 8:04 pm #

      I think it’s useful that we keep having the discussion. There are never fixed answers in writing — or anything creative. That’s why we’re here, I guess!

  4. Valerie J. Long June 18, 2013 at 2:35 pm #

    You’re an Indie if you’re independent enough to publish your next book anytime, anywhere, with or without a publisher you’re already working together with. You’re Indie if it’s your call what’s in the book and what isn’t (not ruling out listening to good reason).
    If you’ve already sold your soul to write only what your agent/publisher tells you to write, so that all your future books belong to someone else, you’re no Indie.
    There are probably more than 50 shades of grey between those definitions…

  5. J.F.Penn June 18, 2013 at 5:12 pm #

    I explain it these days based on something Alison Baverstock talks about – self-publishing can be something as personal as a photobook for your family, or your father’s war memoirs. But indie is about treating it seriously, as a business, as a professional quality product, as something you want to sell and distribute. That’s no judgment on inherent value – but more about the attitude to the details of the publishing process.

  6. Dorothy Hagan June 18, 2013 at 7:02 pm #

    To me indie means courage. Courage to barge in a door when the reception may be less than receptive. Courage to scream “I have something that WILL be voiced” whether it is industry invited, anointed…or not. I will continue to remind people of these self-publishers: Gertrude Stein, Walt Whitman, Virginia Wolff, Beatrix Potter, Edgar Allen Poe, Rudyard Kipling, Henry David Thoreau, Anais Nin, Deepak Chopra, Bernard Shaw, James Joyce, Zane Grey, William E. B. DuBois…Strunk and White for God’s sake! Nearly every writer worth their ink advises new writers to CONSULT STRUNK & WHITE before continuing…Indie means just that: Independent. Ballsy enough to push your art in the door. And that is damn hard for most artists to do.

    • Laurie Stevens June 21, 2013 at 5:20 pm #

      Thanks for the pep talk! It made me proud to call myself an indie

  7. EJSharp June 20, 2013 at 3:55 pm #

    I’m old enough to remember when there were ‘indie’ bands and their music was ranked in separate charts. They’re all considered mainstream now!

  8. Tahlia Newland June 23, 2013 at 2:21 am #

    After a discussion between myself and Niamh Clune recently, we decided to change the Awesome Indies definition from one that talked about the how, to one that focused on the why and what. This was because there are so many small publishers around that have the spirit of independence & treat their authors differently to the old school – a partnership or co-operative relationship, not an employer/employee one & we didn’t want to cut them out. Our new definition is …

    An independent author does not depend on someone else to decide whether, or not, they can express their voice in the world. We create the new trends, offer the new adventures. We make you think, feel and wonder anew. Independent authors listed on the Awesome Indies site have exacting standards, and the creation of a quality product is central to their aims. They choose this path, not because they have no other choice, but because they choose independence.

    I would like to think that all Independent authors have the same exacting standards as those whose books are listed on our site, but unfortunately we all know that isn’t so. I came across an author in a Google+ group boasting about how he didn’t care about grammar & punctuation. Sigh! But if you remove the sentence about quality, the definition is pretty much the same.

    We don’t have the first point because someone who has published in their own publishing company run with a partner, or in a cooperative set up with other authors, hasn’t, strictly speaking, self-published. They’ve published with an independent publisher that they have a share in. If we stick with the word, self published, you cut out everyone who created their own business name before publishing, because they published as a business,not as themselves. It may be cutting hairs but it is the difference between self publishing and indie publishing. No matter how an independent author chooses to publish from the wealth of options now available, the main point is that they (in Niamh’s words) do not depend on someone else to decide whether, or not, they can express their voice in the world.

    It’s a much wider definition than what we have been working with previously, but Andrew Jute suggested to me a long time ago, that anyone who considered themselves indie should be considered indie. He has a point. I don’t suggest that you make it your definition though!

    • ALLi Editorial June 23, 2013 at 9:43 am #

      Very interesting Tahlia and thank you for sharing your thought processes with us — it’s not an easy one and this is a debate around definition that will run and run.

  9. diana kimpton June 25, 2013 at 11:32 am #

    I think control is an important element in being independent. Traditional publishing surrenders most of the control to the publisher. Self-publishing without an author services company keeps all the control with the author. Using a self-publishing company to help you hands over some but not all of the control.

  10. Alexander M Zoltai October 16, 2013 at 3:31 pm #

    Since my comment on an ALLi post on G+ apparently (somehow) led to this post, I decided to feature it on my own blog :-) —> http://nfaa.wordpress.com/2013/10/16/what-is-an-indie-author/

  11. Charles February 21, 2014 at 3:14 pm #

    I’ve recently heard the term Indie Author but wasn’t sure of the definition so I did a quick search and found this page. I am new to the self publishing business and trying to get my start. I have learned so much over the last year and look forward to picking up more information here. I currently have two books on Amazon but haven’t marketed them yet as I keep making improvements.

    Thanks

    Charles

    • Debbie Young February 24, 2014 at 9:18 am #

      Hi Charles, so glad you find this blog so helpful. I’m sure you’d also really benefit from joining ALLi – lots more benefits available to members, who also have access to our invaluable private Facebook forum (ask any self-publishing question there and you’ll get a pretty instant response from current successful self-publishers) plus lots of great benefits such as discounts on various author services. For more information, hop over to the ALLi website – http://www.allianceindependentauthors.org. Best wishes, Debbie Young (ALLi Blog Editor)

  12. Shari Stauch April 7, 2014 at 2:05 pm #

    Brava – you are exactly on point – and I love that term, “creative director.” Lets an author know you don’t have to take the creativity out of the equation to be biz-professional as well.

    Have big fun at LBF – Safe travels and see you next week in Charleston!

  13. Julia Bell September 11, 2014 at 11:41 am #

    I’ve been writing for twenty years and my eighth book will be on line at Christmas. Although I’m self-published, I do have a friend who proofreads for me and a professional illustrator in London, plus my son does the technical stuff for me. I do all my own marketing on Goodreads and Twitter. Does that make me an Indie author? And I’d also like to know if being an Indie author means I can join some sort of club or society. I would love to join like-minded authors and learn more about my art.

    • Julia Bell September 11, 2014 at 11:43 am #

      Oops sorry, just seen comment from Debbie. Will check it out.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. What is an Indie Author? | Cubbys Corner - June 19, 2013

    [...] 18 hours ago by Orna Ross 9 [...]

  2. From ALLi: What IS An Indie Author? - Shawn E. Bell - June 21, 2013

    [...] You can read the whole article HERE. [...]

  3. What is an Indie Author? | - October 4, 2013

    […] 18 hours ago by Orna Ross 9 […]

  4. “What IS An Indie Author?” | Notes from An Alien - October 16, 2013

    […] I’d circled ALLi to see their posts and discovered one called What IS An Indie Author <— That link is to the post on G+ –> here’s one to their blog post on the same topic… […]

  5. Indie Authors Rock! | Book Breath Babe - November 19, 2013

    […] http://selfpublishingadvice.org/what-is-an-indie-author/ […]

  6. Indie or not indie. That is the question! | The Thoughts of Chairman Doug. - December 11, 2013

    […] an indie author? The response was extremely interesting with the top answer being provided by the Alliance of Independent Authors who define it […]

  7. Strong opinions about self-publishing from the ALLi Blog in 2013 | Self-Publishing Advice - December 30, 2013

    […] What IS an Indie Author? by Orna Ross […]

  8. Supporting Indie Writers and their wonderful work | The Whimsical Musings of a Menopausal Miss - December 31, 2013

    […]  – The Alliance of Independent Authors suggests a definition of Indies […]

  9. Picture this: indie authors beware copyright laws while designing books « Ken Ross | Photojournalist & Writer - May 4, 2014

    […] write, paginate, design, and publish their book at little monetary risk, said De Sanctis. Before an indie author jumps into designing his own book he should do a little a research and steer clear of copyright […]

Leave a Reply